blog

What if You Disagree with The Insurance Company’s Settlement Offer?

The insurance company quickly sends you a settlement offer for your car wreck. You need the money desperately. Should you take it?

Something seems wrong…

You got in a car wreck. And the Insurance company couldn’t be more helpful.

They found out about the motor vehicle collision. They made you an offer. And they will even overnight the check to you at their cost.

Oddly, they seem to be in a real rush to get this taken care of.

Why don’t insurers act this way any other time you have a problem?

If you find yourself in this situation, you’re wise to follow your instincts. No matter how much you need the money, and no matter how good it looks, you’re probably not getting a fair offer.

It doesn’t always mean the insurance company is up to no good. Sometimes they give you a fair settlement offer.

But most of the time, they’re giving you a lowball offer. And if they can get you to accept it by offering you a small chunk of cash now, they might save themselves thousands, or even tens of thousands of dollars later on.

So, if you get an offer from the other driver’s insurer, and they also promise to send the check to you overnight, what can you do if you don’t feel comfortable with the whole situation?

First, Understand How This Works Legally

The other driver’s insurance company works for its own customer, not for you. One section of the Texas Insurance Code lists unfair settlement practices, like failing to try in good faith to reach a prompt, fair settlement once the insurer’s liability is reasonably clear. But that section covers claims by the insurer’s own insureds and beneficiaries. It also says it gives no right to sue to a third party, like you, who has a claim against the other driver. So you can’t use that law to sue the other driver’s insurer over a low offer. It’s different if the offer comes from your own insurance company on a claim under your own policy. Then that section can apply, and another section lets a person who suffers actual damages caused by an unfair settlement practice sue the insurer.

If you accept it, then you can’t pursue compensation for this particular accident ever again, even if you get ripped off.

What if you find out you have whiplash or a traumatic brain injury? Such injuries may not show up until weeks or even months after your wreck.

Also, in Texas, you have the statute of limitations on your side. That means Texas law generally gives you two years to file a personal injury lawsuit.

So, no matter how urgent the insurance company makes the situation appear, you have absolutely no obligation to act quickly.

And resist that urge, even if you really need the money now. This low offer could cost you tens of thousands of dollars in the long run.

You Can Negotiate Every Detail of Your Claim

Insurers like people who act like sheep. Simply follow what they say, let them clean out your wallet, and everything’s going to be just fine (at least for the insurer anyway)!

For starters, you don’t have to give a recorded statement to a claims adjuster. Remember, they represent the insurer, not you. And they have years of experience in negotiation, which means they know what to do to pressure you into accepting an offer not in your best interest.

Their job is to make the insurance company money. They get promotions (or not) based on how well they do that.

You don’t have to sign any agreements the insurer provides. You don’t have to (and you shouldn’t) take your car to the auto repair shop the insurer recommends.

Typically, they have contracts in place with repair shops to keep repair costs low. So, these repair shops will use cheap parts, or avoid doing certain repairs entirely, to help out the insurer.

If the insurer totals your vehicle and you think it’s worth more, you can try to negotiate. According to the Texas Department of Insurance, an insurer will likely total a car when the cost to repair it is about the same as or more than the car’s value, and some companies might total a car even when repairs would cost less. You can ask what source the company used to decide your car’s value. Be ready to show what the car would sell for in your area, like quotes from used car dealers and local ads for similar vehicles.

Basically, you can negotiate nearly every aspect of your claim with the insurance company.

Talking With a Personal Injury Attorney

Finally, if you don’t want to deal with all this, or if you just want to show the insurer you’re not messing around, consider hiring a personal injury attorney.

They offer free consultations. So, you can find out if you should accept the insurer’s offer.

You can read about our free consultation and fees.

You have plenty of tools at your disposal if you don’t like the insurance company’s offer. They won’t let you know about any of those.

But you can absolutely defend yourself. And you can find help in a personal injury attorney if you feel uncomfortable or overwhelmed.

Suggested Reading

Should you settle quickly after your accident?

Does Texas law favor victims or insurers?

Should you repair or replace your vehicle after an accident?

What are reasons a lawyer might not take your case?

Dig More

Should I accept a quick settlement offer from the insurance company after a car accident?

No matter how much you need the money, and no matter how good it looks, you're probably not getting a fair offer. Most of the time, they're giving you a lowball offer. And if they can get you to accept it by offering you a small chunk of cash now, they might save themselves thousands, or even tens of thousands of dollars later on.

How long do I have to file a car accident claim in Texas?

In Texas, you have the statute of limitations on your side. That means that you have two years from the date of your collision to pursue your claim in court. So, no matter how urgent the insurance company makes the situation appear, you have absolutely no obligation to act quickly.

Do I have to give a recorded statement to the insurance claims adjuster?

You don't have to give a recorded statement to a claims adjuster. Remember, they represent the insurer, not you. And they have years of experience in negotiation, which means they know what to do to pressure you into accepting an offer not in your best interest.

Can I negotiate with the insurance company on more than just the settlement amount?

Basically, you can negotiate nearly every aspect of your claim with the insurance company. You don't have to sign any agreements the insurer provides. You don't have to (and you shouldn't) take your car to the auto repair shop the insurer recommends. If the insurer totals your vehicle, you can appeal that decision.

How much does it cost to hire a personal injury attorney to dispute an insurance settlement?

They offer free consultations. So, you can find out if you should accept the insurer's offer. And, they also don't charge anything until after you win your claim.

Written by: — Online Marketing and Business Development

Daniel Cook leads online marketing and business development at Mullen & Mullen and provides research for case development. He holds a master’s degree in psychology from the University of Arkansas and spent years assisting research on rehabilitation and the effects of accidents and disability on psychological health.

Get Your Free Case Evaluation Now