You or a loved one gets hurt. In Texas, it might be completely legal for the big insurer to screw you out of your money. But there is help.
Abraham Lincoln said in his famous Gettysburg Address:
“…that this nation, under God, shall have a new birth of freedom – and that government of the people, by the people, for the people, shall not perish from the earth.”
Well, our government’s certainly remained intact. So those words have held true.
But a government of, by, and for the people – that part certainly isn’t true at all times today.
States differ in how much protection they give insurers and consumers. In Texas, the scales are tipped in favor of the insurance companies:
- For example, one guard at the Giddings State School won her worker’s compensation claim against the Texas Office of Risk Management. It took her 4 years to file and win her claim. An insurer can go to court to challenge a final decision on whether a worker’s injury is covered, or on their income or death benefits. Normally, if it does and the worker wins on an issue it appealed, the insurer must pay the worker’s reasonable attorney’s fees for that appeal. But state agencies are different. Texas law says the workers’ comp laws don’t allow claims or damages against a state agency beyond what the Texas Tort Claims Act allows. Because that Act doesn’t expressly provide for attorney’s fees, a Texas appeals court has held that the state’s risk management office is immune from paying them. So the Texas Office of Risk Management appealed this worker’s decision, knowing this school employee would have a difficult time finding any attorney willing to take her case on.
- In many cases, attorneys don’t take on small worker’s comp injury claims, which still amount to thousands for the victims, because attorneys’ fees would eat up the whole value of the claim.
- Claims adjusters can say they will fairly address your situation, with no real intention of doing so. For example, they might try to settle your claim in just a few days so they don’t have to pay you for future medical conditions. Texas’s Office of Public Insurance Counsel warns that the other driver’s insurer will make you sign a release for all claims, and once you sign it, you won’t get more money for your injury.
- Certain damages are capped in Texas including damages in medical malpractice claims. For example, Texas law caps noneconomic damages, such as pain and suffering, at $250,000 per claimant against doctors and other health care providers, no matter how many are sued. Hospitals and other health care institutions face separate caps. The idea is this keeps the costs of medical care down. Medical expense costs continue to rise, however, and consumers like you have been barred from recovering fair damages.
How Did Insurance Companies Get So Much Power to Take Advantage of Texas Consumers?
Part of the answer is in Texas Supreme Court decisions about the state’s insurance laws.
One of those decisions was Allstate Insurance Co. v. Watson (1994). A woman hurt in a car wreck sued the other driver’s insurance company for unfair claim settlement practices. The Texas Supreme Court held that a third party claimant like her could not sue the insurer directly for those practices under the Texas Insurance Code.
Today, the Texas Insurance Code itself says this. Its list of unfair claim settlement practices covers claims made by the people an insurer insures and by beneficiaries. But the code says that list gives a third party no right to sue when the third party has a claim against someone covered by a liability policy. So if the other driver’s insurer handles your claim unfairly, that part of the code does not let you sue the insurer.
Your rights are stronger when the claim is on your own policy. Say your own insurer doesn’t try in good faith to settle your claim promptly and fairly once it’s reasonably clear it owes the claim. Texas law lets you sue it for the actual damages this causes you. If you win, you can also recover court costs and reasonable attorney’s fees. If the insurer acted knowingly, the judge or jury may award up to three times your actual damages.
Your own insurer also has deadlines. In most cases, it must acknowledge your claim and start investigating within 15 days after it gets notice of the claim. Once it has the items and forms it asked for, it generally has 15 business days to tell you in writing whether it accepts or rejects the claim. If it owes the claim and doesn’t follow these rules, it can owe you interest and reasonable attorney’s fees on top of the claim.
Think the System is Rigged and Unfair? In Texas, You’d Be Right!
We could bore you with all the legal intricacies and details. But you don’t want to spend your time reading that.
Just know that if you’re involved in a disagreement with an insurance company, they have more power than you do and will utilize that power to limit your recovery – even for immoral reasons. But Texas law may make it completely legal.
So whenever you interact with an insurance company, it’s wise to have a skilled injury attorney on your side.
Suggested Reading
How do wrongful death claims work in Texas?
What is personal injury protection (PIP) insurance and should you have it?
Must you give a recorded statement to insurance company?
What if you are hurt in Texas and the at-fault driver has no insurance?
Dig More
Does Texas law favor insurance companies over injury victims?
Just know that if you're involved in a disagreement with an insurance company, they have more power than you do and will utilize that power to limit your recovery – even for immoral reasons. But Texas law may make it completely legal.
How did insurance companies gain so much power over Texas consumers?
It all stems from a number of Texas Supreme Court decisions in the 1990s. Prior to that, Texans had reasonably fair legal rights versus insurance companies. But in the 1990s, the Texas Supreme Court was heavily Republican. So many voting decisions took the side of the insurance companies. For example, 132 insurance cases were decided by the Texas Supreme Court in the 1990s. Of those, insurance companies won a whopping 71%.
Are damages capped in Texas personal injury cases?
Certain damages are capped in Texas including damages in medical malpractice claims. The idea is this keeps the costs of medical care down. Medical expense costs continue to rise, however, and consumers like you have been barred from recovering fair damages.
Can a Texas insurance claims adjuster settle your claim unfairly?
Claims adjusters can say they will fairly address your situation, with no real intention of doing so. For example, they might try to settle your claim in just a few days so they don't have to pay you for future medical conditions.
Should I hire an attorney when dealing with an insurance company in Texas?
So whenever you interact with an insurance company, it's wise to have a skilled injury attorney on your side.

