Want to keep your case private? Learn how settlement confidentiality works and what it can’t do.
Diane Vasilion, 52, was left with brain damage and partial paralysis after a 1994 car accident involving multiple vehicles. In 2000, she was awarded $35 million, then the largest amount in Illinois state history.
Said nicely, many friends and long-lost family members tend to suddenly come out of the woodwork when they hear about this. And unfortunately, sometimes scammers approach people with large financial awards. Other relatives might get jealous and angry, thinking the award was excessive.
A “settlement confidentiality agreement” can help. In a confidential settlement, the parties promise each other to keep the terms of the settlement, such as the amount, secret between them. But an agreement between the parties can’t guarantee that nothing about your case becomes public.
Texas law does set some limits. Under Rule 76a of the Texas Rules of Civil Procedure, court records are presumed to be open to the public. The rule even treats an unfiled settlement agreement as a court record if it tries to keep secret information about matters that have a probable adverse effect on public health or safety (not counting any reference to the dollar amount). And if a state or local government body is a party to your settlement, Texas public information law makes the settlement agreement public information unless another law makes it confidential.
Why else might you want a settlement confidentiality clause?
Besides privacy regarding the payout amount and details of the personal injury claim, here are some others:
• Plaintiffs often like confidentiality, too. You may be able to use confidentiality as a bargaining chip to increase the value of your claim.
• You don’t want the public to know about something private, like a medical condition.
• You may have been fired from a job or harassed for personal reasons. Confidentiality keeps these things private so you don’t have worry about damage to your reputation.
• You’re concerned others might view your case, and you personally, as “ridiculous” or “absurd” (it isn’t), and you want to protect your reputation.
Why do defendants want settlement confidentiality?
Many times, the defending party is interested in settlement confidentiality (although they may not think of it).
Here’s why they might have that interest:
• They don’t want damage to their personal or business reputation.
• They don’t want the public to know the details of their negligent behavior.
• Sometimes, when people see someone get successfully sued, they try their luck and attempt to sue the entity for the same or other reasons in “me too” lawsuits.
• A plaintiff requesting confidentiality can also help them settle litigation when there’s multiple defendants.
Why would you not want settlement confidentiality?
From the plaintiff’s side, your side, there aren’t too many reasons you wouldn’t want settlement confidentiality.
Some choose not to have settlement confidentiality because they are angry with what has happened to them and the defendant’s actions. They want the public to know the real story.
You can do things either way.
Ultimately, it’s up to you. You need to understand the potential ramifications of keeping your personal injury settlement confidential or letting it go public.
Suggested Reading
What is proportionate responsibility in Texas? Why should you care?
The top reason slip and fall cases are not successful
How do Texas Public transport (Bus & Train) injury claims work?
What if you disagree with the insurance company’s settlement offer?
Dig More
What is a settlement confidentiality agreement in a personal injury case?
In a confidential settlement, the parties promise each other to keep the terms of the settlement, such as the amount, secret between them. But an agreement between the parties can't guarantee that nothing about your case becomes public.
Can a settlement confidentiality agreement keep Texas court records private?
Under Rule 76a of the Texas Rules of Civil Procedure, court records are presumed to be open to the public. The rule even treats an unfiled settlement agreement as a court record if it tries to keep secret information about matters that have a probable adverse effect on public health or safety.
Why would a plaintiff want a confidentiality clause in a personal injury settlement?
You may be able to use confidentiality as a bargaining chip to increase the value of your claim. You don't want the public to know about something private, like a medical condition. You may have been fired from a job or harassed for personal reasons. Confidentiality keeps these things private so you don't have to worry about damage to your reputation.
Why do defendants want settlement confidentiality in personal injury cases?
They don't want damage to their personal or business reputation. They don't want the public to know the details of their negligent behavior. Sometimes, when people see someone get successfully sued, they try their luck and attempt to sue the entity for the same or other reasons in 'me too' lawsuits.
Why would someone choose not to keep their personal injury settlement confidential?
Some choose not to have settlement confidentiality because they are angry with what has happened to them and the defendant's actions. They want the public to know the real story.

